How GDP Hides Industrial Decline
For the past few years I have been mulling a paradox: U.S. GDP keeps going up, yet it seems like we make less stuff and that most of the smart people I know work fake jobs. Growing up in the nineties, most of my toys and clothes had tags saying “Made in Hong Kong” or “Made in Vietnam.” But the high-skill, high-tech goods—the washing machine, the car, my computer—were often made in America. Now? From my e-bike to my laptop, from my refrigerator to my mattress, very few goods I own, high-tech or low-tech, were made in the USA. Meanwhile, I have heard arguments that America is actually making more things than ever. According to The Economist, lost jobs are due to automation, not foreign competition, and it is a good thing that machines have liberated us from factory work and enabled more service jobs. Everyone from the American Enterprise Institute to The Wall Street Journal to Wikipedia agrees that U.S. manufacturing has not just not significantly fallen—but it has never been higher. Som
Ed Brown/Frances Perkins Building in Washington, D.C. For the past few years I have been mulling a paradox: U.S. GDP keeps going up, yet it seems like we make less stuff and that most of the smart people I know work fake jobs. Growing up in the nineties, most of my toys and clothes had tags saying “Made in Hong Kong” or “Made in Vietnam.” But the high-skill, high-tech goods—the washing machine, the car, my computer—were often made in America. Now? From my e-bike to my laptop, from my refrigerator to my mattress, very few goods I own, high-tech or low-tech, were made in the USA. Meanwhile, I ha
related reading
- New Article: How GDP Hides Industrial Declineletter.palladiummag.com
- Worse Than the Great Depression: What Experts Are Missing About American Manufacturing Declinenist.gov
- GDP and prosperity across technology pathsphiliptrammell.substack.com
- Understanding the Decline in Manufacturing Employment | Research Highlights | Upjohn Instituteupjohn.org
- How Technology Grows (a Restatement of Definite Optimism)danwang.co
- Questions · Patrick Collisonpatrickcollison.com
- 1.2 History’s hockey stick – Microeconomicsbooks.core-econ.org
- CONVERSABLE ECONOMIST: Including Illegal Activities in GDP: Drugs, Prostitution, Gamblingconversableeconomist.blogspot.com
- Phil Trammell & Chad Jones - GDP and VSLphiliptrammell.com
- Luis Garicano 🇪🇺🇺🇦 on X: "We stopped everything to write an answer (link below) to Paul Krugman's two posts of today (one informal, one with a simple model) arguing that Europe is broadly not falling behind the United States. The change measured by the Draghi report, he argues, is mostly due to growth" / Xx.com
- Sự suy vi của tầng lớp lao động nền kinh tế lớn nhất thế giới | Vietstockvietstock.vn
- America’s Widening Productivity Gapproject-syndicate.org