Why AI doctors should not be FDA regulated - by Dan Elton
The FDA is a sacred cow in medicine. Thus, it was refreshing when I saw a recent critique of the FDA’s current system for AI regulation published in PLOS: Digital Health. The authors include medical researchers from the Harvard T. H Chan School of Public Health, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, and the UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. They are a bit shy about how they state it, but their proposal is rather radical — they call for a major curtailment of the FDA’s role in AI regulation and a shift towards decentralized systems for AI oversight.
The FDA is a sacred cow in medicine. Thus, it was refreshing when I saw a recent critique of the FDA’s current system for AI regulation published in PLOS: Digital Health.1 The authors include medical researchers from the Harvard T. H Chan School of Public Health, Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, and the UK’s National Institute for Health and Care Excellence. They are a bit shy about how they state it, but their proposal is rather radical — they call for a major curtailment of the FDA’s role in AI regulation and a shift towards decentralized systems for AI oversight. The authors argue…
related reading
- The case for ensuring that powerful AIs are controlled — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Medical AI Safety: We have a problem. – Lauren Oakden-Raynerlaurenoakdenrayner.com
- Why AI Will Save the World | Andreessen Horowitza16z.com
- The Case for Big Action to Regulate Artificial Intelligencechamath.substack.com
- Why FDA Must Increase Transparency of Medical Devices Powered by Artificial Intelligence | The Pew Charitable Trustspewtrusts.org
- Radical Optionality — Governing Transformative AI Under Uncertaintyradical-optionality.ai
- The Case for Big Action to Regulate Artificial Intelligencechamath.substack.com
- The Case Against AI Control Research — LessWronglesswrong.com
- AI for medicine is overhyped right now - by Dan Eltonmoreisdifferent.substack.com
- Medical AI Safety: Doing it wrong. – Lauren Oakden-Raynerlaurenoakdenrayner.com
- Why You Should Almost Never Use AI to Write Anything Substantiveerichgrunewald.com
- The AI rules that US policymakers are considering, explainedvox.com