Reversals in psychology
26th January 2020 • A list of exaggerated psychological phenomena • Confidence: High that I'm representing the current evidence well, low that all of these will stay reversed. • Topic importance: 5 / 10 • Content notes: I am not a social scientist. • Reading time: 20 mins. • Cross-posted here.
Now a crowdsourced project elsewhere . Seeking volunteers! A medical reversal is when an existing treatment is found to actually be useless or harmful. Psychology has in recent years been racking up reversals: in fact only 40-65% of its classic social results were replicated, in the weakest sense of finding ‘significant’ results in the same direction. (Even in those that replicated, the average effect found was half the originally reported effect.) Such errors are far less costly to society than medical errors, but it’s still pollution, so here’s the cleanup. 1 Psychology is not alone: medicin
related reading
- Psychology Research Is Mostly Fineastralcodexten.com
- Barnum effect - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org
- Psychology of Human Misjudgment (Transcript) by Charlie Mungerfs.blog
- The Algernon Argument · Gwern.netgwern.net
- Hotel Concierge — The Stanford Marshmallow Prison Experimenthotelconcierge.tumblr.com
- Gwern's Most Important Writing (in essays, tweets, book reviews, and other forms) - Alexey Guzeyguzey.com
- Beware The Man Of One Studyslatestarcodex.com
- New paradigm for psychology just droppedexperimental-history.com
- Revised Psychology of Human Misjudmentfsmisc.s3.ca-central-1.amazonaws.com
- Why Facts Don’t Change Our Minds | The New Yorkernewyorker.com
- The Control Group Is Out Of Controlslatestarcodex.com
- Hawthorne effect - Wikipediaen.wikipedia.org