What I learned from debating the Science of Reading more than 20 years ago is still true | Leigh Patel
These principles are fairly obvious to anyone who has a grasp of the political economy of education in a racial capitalist society. I have three stories that I hope are of help in all the noise of “scientific reading” now becoming policy, with teacher education programs scrambling to be in compliance with freshly minted state laws. Story One: Reading happens in specific places and contexts One of the best and most challenging professional experiences I ever had was working with a young person, an 8th grader whose school file had the word ‘illiterate’ in many documents. When I was first paired with Brandon in the university-run reading clinic, I was, frankly, terrified of failing at the task, further harming a person whom school had already harmed. At the time, I was teaching 7th grade while also taking classes at a university because I had lots of questions about patterns of oppression and exclusion I witnessed but nowhere in my school day or community to talk about them. Even though
What I learned then that is still true: Binaries kill nuance. Research is never neutral. Everything is political and cultural. No singular reading approach will save us from racial capitalism let alone help us build freedom. These principles are fairly obvious to anyone who has a grasp of the political economy of education in a racial capitalist society. I have three stories that I hope are of help in all the noise of “scientific reading” now becoming policy, with teacher education programs scrambling to be in compliance with freshly minted state laws. Story One: Reading happens in specific pl
saved by
related reading
- How to Stop Killing the Love of Reading | Cult of Pedagogycultofpedagogy.com
- A Call to Action: What We Know About Adolescent Literacy Instruction - National Council of Teachers of Englishncte.org
- The “Invisible Knapsack": Rip it open. Spend it down.knowlesteachers.org
- Reading is magic - by Sam Kriss - Numb at the Lodgesamkriss.substack.com
- What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problemaeon.co
- Two More Things to Unlearn from School — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Reading is magicsubstack.com
- How a flawed idea is teaching millions of kids to be poor readers | At a Loss for Words | APM Reportsapmreports.org
- What Did We Learn From Lex Fridman's Book List?regressstudies.substack.com
- In Praise of Not Not Reading | The Point Magazinethepointmag.com
- What we think is a decline in literacy is a design problemaeon.co
- Dyslexia and the Reading Wars | The New Yorkernewyorker.com