The Sublime Luxury of Saying No - Nomads Vagabonds
Imagine a room full of people trying to disarm a bomb. They are all very smart. They all agree the bomb is dangerous. The problem is, they cannot agree on a strategy. One faction insists on cutting the blue wire. Another argues for red. A third wants to freeze the ignition mechanism first. A fourth thinks that the mere existence of the bomb means everyone’s going to die regardless. The clock ticks exponentially faster. Tick. Tick. Tick. Meanwhile, outside the room, another group is shouting in unison that the bomb is actually a piñata full of cancer-curing, immortality-granting candy. Also, if we don’t hit it soon, China will steal our candy instead. This is a confused analogy AI policy in 2025. The debate is often framed as a simple conflict: safety advocates versus accelerationists. Caution versus progress. Industry Super-PACS versus scrappy activists. This framing is neat. It fits our political archetypes. But it misses the critical dynamic shaping the future. The real story is one
Imagine a room full of people trying to disarm a bomb. They are all very smart. They all agree the bomb is dangerous. The problem is, they cannot agree on a strategy. One faction insists on cutting the blue wire. Another argues for red. A third wants to freeze the ignition mechanism first. A fourth thinks that the mere existence of the bomb means everyone’s going to die regardless. The clock ticks exponentially faster. Tick. Tick. Tick. Meanwhile, outside the room, another group is shouting in unison that the bomb is actually a piñata full of cancer-curing, immortality-granting candy.…
related reading
- The current bottleneck is political will, not research — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Dario Amodei — Policy on the AI Exponentialdarioamodei.com
- The Possessed Machines: Dostoevsky's Demons and the Coming AGI Catastrophepossessedmachines.com
- Which side of the AI safety community are you in? — LessWronglesswrong.com
- In search of a dynamist vision for safe superhuman AIhelentoner.substack.com
- You Need A Theory of Victory - by Jason Hausenloyfirstscattering.com
- AI Populism's Warning Shotsjasmi.news
- Selective Optimism: a critique of AI 2040 - by Richard Ngomindthefuture.info
- Applause Lights — LessWronglesswrong.com
- A Long Sequence of Small, Correct Decisionscalebwatney.substack.com
- Where I agree and disagree with Eliezer — LessWronglesswrong.com
- d/acc: one year latervitalik.eth.limo