taboo
tl;dr: when having a disagreement involving a complex concept X, consider saying what you actually mean by X, or both parties might just be talking past each other! Taboo is one of my favorite techniques. I find taboo extremely useful at resolving confusing problems. The idea of taboo is as follows: For instance, suppose you were discussing judgement. A hypothetical conversation: JJ: It’s bad to judge people, because it makes you have negative feelings towards them and betrays your values of loving and helping other people. ST: No, it’s good to judge people, because it helps you learn what actions you want to avoid, and it also allows you to help other people course-correct when they are doing bad things. Resolution JJ: Oh, now that we’re using taboo, I guess what I really meant was that it’s bad to label people, because this results in you being negatively oriented towards them, harming both parties. ST: Oh I see. And what I meant was actually that it’s useful to appraise people’s act
tl;dr: when having a disagreement involving a complex concept X, consider saying what you actually mean by X, or both parties might just be talking past each other! Taboo is one of my favorite techniques. I find taboo extremely useful at resolving confusing problems. The idea of taboo is as follows: Often, two people discussing concept X will have some disagreements. Both parties might say seemingly reasonable things about X, which are contradictory. Often, the source of confusion is that the two parties were actually using X to point to distinct concepts Y, Z! In order to resolve such…
saved by
related reading
- Taboo Your Words — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Taboo Your Words — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Judgynessjason.ml
- how to think fastnotebook.neelr.dev
- Home - The XY Problemxyproblem.info
- Why I Stopped Arguing With Peoplewangcong.org
- Questions That Make People Say Things They've Never Said Beforepointingatthings.substack.com
- Fake thinking and real thinking - Joe Carlsmithjoecarlsmith.com
- You're allowed to be inconsistentmindingourway.com
- Decoupling vs Contextualizing Norms — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Plans you're not supposed to talk aboutdynomight.net
- The hostile telepaths problem — LessWronglesswrong.com