Giving people money helped less than I thought it would
Just give people money. It's the simple, brute-force solution to so many problems. In low-income countries, charities are sometimes measured against whether their interventions are better than simply giving people cash. Even in high-income countries like the U.S., when disaster strikes, often the best thing you can do is get money into the hands of affected people immediately. They know whether they should use it to buy gas, rent an Airbnb or fly to their cousin's house one state over. So it wasn't that crazy to assume — particularly once promising pilots were released — that the same should be true for addressing chronic poverty in high-income countries. If you give a new mom a few hundred dollars a month or a homeless man one thousand dollars a month, that's gotta show up in the data, right? Alas. A few years back we got really serious about studying cash transfers, and rigorous research began in cities all across America. Some programs targeted the homeless, some new mothers and som
Giving people money helped less than I thought it would Ending the war on poverty will take more than cash transfers Kelsey Piper Aug 19, 2025 677 61 106 Share U.S. singer Eartha Kitt is seen at the end of the Poor People March, on June 19, 1968, in Washington, D.C. (Photo by ARNOLD SACHS/AFP via Getty Images) Just give people money . It's the simple, brute-force solution to so many problems. In low-income countries, charities are sometimes measured against whether their interventions are better than simply giving people cash. Even in high-income countries like the U.S., when disaster strikes,
Explore this link on the map →related reading
- What is effective altruism? | Effective Altruismeffectivealtruism.org
- The Causal Effect of Income is (Often) Zeromaximum-progress.com
- Global inequality is huge — but so is the opportunity for people in high-income countries to support poor people | Our World in Dataourworldindata.org
- Comparing charities: How big is the difference? · Giving What We Cangivingwhatwecan.org
- Study: Cash aid is a boon to the health of infants and little kids : Goats and Soda : NPRnpr.org
- The Levers That Money Can’t Pullmoretothat.com
- 3 evidence-based ways anyone can have a real impact | 80,000 Hours80000hours.org
- Why effective altruism is not effective - ABC Religion & Ethicsabc.net.au
- Effective nonprofitsblog.jacobtrefethen.com
- Developing the science of science - Works in Progress Magazineworksinprogress.co
- The Deaths of Effective Altruism | WIREDwired.com
- Giving the first £10,000 | Rohan's Ramblesselvaradov.net