On Smarm
Last month, Isaac Fitzgerald, the newly hired editor of BuzzFeed's newly created books section, made a remarkable but not entirely surprising announcement: He was not interested in publishing negative book reviews. In place of "the scathing takedown rip," Fitzgerald said, he desired to promote a positive community experience. A community, even one dedicated to positivity, needs an enemy to define itself against. BuzzFeed's motto, the attitude that drives its success, is an explicit "No haters." The site is one of the leading voices of the moment, thriving in the online sharing economy, in which agreeability is popularity, and popularity is value. (Upworthy, the next iteration, has gone ahead and made its name out of the premise.) There is more at work here than mere good feelings. "No haters" is a sentiment older and more wide-reaching than BuzzFeed. There is a consensus, or something that has assumed the tone of a consensus, that we are living, to our disadvantage, in an age of snark—
Last month, Isaac Fitzgerald, the newly hired editor of BuzzFeed's newly created books section, made a remarkable but not entirely surprising announcement: He was not interested in publishing negative book reviews . In place of "the scathing takedown rip," Fitzgerald said, he desired to promote a positive community experience. A community, even one dedicated to positivity, needs an enemy to define itself against. BuzzFeed's motto, the attitude that drives its success, is an explicit "No haters." The site is one of the leading voices of the moment, thriving in the online sharing economy, in whi
related reading
- In Favor of Niceness, Community, and Civilizationslatestarcodex.com
- Sort By Controversialslatestarcodex.com
- Be Nice....Or Else!!!!mentalhellth.xyz
- Rule Thinkers In, Not Out — LessWronglesswrong.com
- The Socially-Conscious Mean Girl - by eliza mclambwordsfromeliza.com
- What It Means To Be An Intellectual (Aaron Swartz's Raw Thought)aaronsw.com
- Like This or Die, by Christian Lorentzenharpers.org
- Poser ethics - by rayne fisher-quann - internet princessinternetprincess.substack.com
- The NYT Book Review Is Everything Book Criticism Shouldn't Becurrentaffairs.org
- “mặt dày”akwaabatung.substack.com
- Miniver Cheevy: Scott Alexander Siskind & Slate Star Codexminiver.blogspot.com
- One year of envy, lies, and greed - by Sam Krisssamkriss.substack.com