Einstein's Speed — LessWrong

lesswrong.com · 7,156 words · saved by 1 readers

Yesterday I argued that the Powers Beyond Science are actually a standard and necessary part of the social process of science. In particular, scientists must call upon their powers of individual rationality to decide what ideas to test, in advance of the sort of definite experiments that Science demands to bless an idea as confirmed. The ideal of Science does not try to specify this process—we don't suppose that any public authority knows how individual scientists should think—but this doesn't mean the process is unimportant. A readily understandable, non-disturbing example: A scientist identifies a strong mathematical regularity in the cumulative data of previous experiments. But the corresponding hypothesis has not yet made and confirmed a novel experimental prediction—which his academic field demands; this is one of those fields where you can perform controlled experiments without too much trouble. Thus the individual scientist has readily understandable, rational reasons to bel

x Einstein's Speed — LessWrong Science and Rationality Physics Practice & Philosophy of Science Rationality Personal Blog 74 Einstein's Speed by Eliezer Yudkowsky 21st May 2008 10 min read 35 74 Yesterday I argued that the Powers Beyond Science are actually a standard and necessary part of the social process of science. In particular, scientists must call upon their powers of individual rationality to decide what ideas to test, in advance of the sort of definite experiments that Science demands to bless an idea as confirmed. The ideal of Science does not try to specify this process—we don't su

Einstein's Speed — LessWrong

related reading