Scissor Labels
A specific shape of online debate caught my attention in 2020. As I’ve reflected on the past year, I’ve realized that this pattern is happening frequently but is rarely understood.
We live in an age of constant narrative conflict. But today, not every battle is legible to the untrained observer. While some grifts are plainly perpetrated by would-be thought leaders, other battles for narrative control are hiding in plain sight, happening under the guise of intellectual debate. When these battles go unrecognized for what they are, even the best among us fall victim to meaningless conversations that waste the time of those involved. In this piece, I introduce the concept of "scissor labels," why they foment controversy, and how they're different from other linguistic debate
Explore this link on the map →related reading
- Metalabelmetalabel.com
- Creeping as a Service (CraaS)every.to
- Can Things Be Both Popular And Silenced? | Slate Star Codexslatestarcodex.com
- The "Scooby Doo" psyopgarbageday.email
- 31. Gabe Whaley - Playing the Crowd & Outlasting the Hype — Dialecticjacksondahl.com
- Taboo Your Words — LessWronglesswrong.com
- Dumb and shameful until it's notgarbageday.email
- ftlsid on X: "starting to feel very resistant towards participating in discourse about the meta - about worldview, interpersonal dynamics, the nature of people, approaches to life, etc. it’s very easy to get involved in, and is very populartwitter.com
- Bryan Lehrerbryanlehrer.com
- Your Feed Is the Product of a Stealth Marketing Campaignvulture.com
- Monthly Roundup #40: March 2026 - by Zvi Mowshowitzthezvi.substack.com
- Wait okay just hold up just wait a sectilde.club