Verification
If the human designers of an AI are not to be burdened with ensuring that what their AI knows is correct, then the AI will have to ensure it itself. It will have to be able to verify the knowledge that it has gained or been given. Giving an AI the ability to verify its knowledge is no small thing. It is in fact a very big thing, not easy to do. Often a bit of knowledge can be written very compactly, whereas its verification is very complex. It is easy to say "there is a book on the table", but very complex to express even a small part of its verification, such as the visual and tactile sensations involved in picking up the book. It is easy to define an operator such as "I can get to the lunchroom by going down one floor", but to verify this one must refer to executable routines for finding and descending the stairs, recognizing the lunchroom, etc. These routines involve enormously greater detail and closed-loop contingencies, such as opening doors, the possibility of a stairway being c
Verification Verification Rich Sutton 11/14/2001 If the human designers of an AI are not to be burdened with ensuring that what their AI knows is correct, then the AI will have to ensure it itself. It will have to be able to verify the knowledge that it has gained or been given. Giving an AI the ability to verify its knowledge is no small thing. It is in fact a very big thing, not easy to do. Often a bit of knowledge can be written very compactly, whereas its verification is very complex. It is easy to say "there is a book on the table", but very complex to express even a small part of its ver
Explore this link on the map →related reading
- Self-Verification, The Key to AIincompleteideas.net
- Asymmetry of verification and verifier’s rule - Jason Weijasonwei.net
- When AI Writes the World's Software, Who Verifies It? — Leonardo de Mouraleodemoura.github.io
- [2004.07213] Toward Trustworthy AI Development: Mechanisms for Supporting Verifiable Claimsarxiv.org
- Oversight Assistants: Turning Compute into Understandingbounded-regret.ghost.io
- Automatic Formal Verification for Code Generationlogicalintelligence.com
- The Compute Verification Postfirstscattering.com
- 2023 letter | Zhengdongzhengdongwang.com
- Convictionconviction.com
- AGI is an Engineering Problem - by Jason Hausenloyinferencemagazine.substack.com
- Current AIs seem pretty misaligned to meblog.redwoodresearch.org
- Solve math, solve everything. — Math, Inc.math.inc