✳flâneur — a map of the web's best reading

Fake Fake Utility Functions - LessWrong

lesswrong.com · 1,814 words · saved by 1 readers

Followup to: Most of my posts over the last month... Every now and then, you run across someone who has discovered the One Great Moral Principle, of which all other values are a mere derivative consequence. I run across more of these people than you do. Only in my case, it's people who know the amazingly simple utility function that is all you need to program into an artificial superintelligence and then everything will turn out fine... It's incredible how one little issue can require so much prerequisite material. My original schedule called for "Fake Utility Functions" to follow "Fake Justification" on Oct 31. Talk about your planning fallacy. I've been planning to post on this topic in "just a few days" for the past month. A fun little demonstration of underestimated inferential distances. You see, before I wrote this post, it occurred to me that if I wanted to properly explain the problem of fake utility functions, it would be helpful to illustrate a mistake about what a simple optimization criterion implied. The strongest real-world example I knew was the Tragedy of Group Selectionism. At first I thought I'd mention it in passing, within "Fake Utility Functions", but I decided the Tragedy of Group Selectionism was a long enough story that it needed its own blog post... So I started to write "The Tragedy of Group Selectionism". A few hours later, I noticed that I hadn't said anything about group selectionism yet. I'd been too busy introducing basic evolutionary concepts. Select all the introductory stuff, cut, Compose New Post, paste, title... "An Alien God". Then keep writing until the "Alien God" post gets too long, and start taking separate subjects out into their own posts: "The Wonder of Evolution", "Evolutions Are Stupid", and at this point it became clear that, since I was planning to say a few words on evolution anyway, that was the time. Besides, a basic familiarity with evolution would help to shake people loose of their human assumptions wh

x Fake Fake Utility Functions — LessWrong List of Links Summaries Personal Blog 45 Fake Fake Utility Functions by Eliezer Yudkowsky 6th Dec 2007 4 min read 9 45 Followup to: Most of my posts over the last month... Every now and then, you run across someone who has discovered the One Great Moral Principle, of which all other values are a mere derivative consequence. I run across more of these people than you do. Only in my case, it's people who know the amazingly simple utility function that is all you need to program into an artificial superintelligence and then everything will turn out fine..

Explore this link on the map →

related reading