✳flâneur — a map of the web's best reading

Orthogonality Thesis — LessWrong

lesswrong.com · 4,573 words · saved by 1 readers

Introduction The Orthogonality Thesis asserts that there can exist arbitrarily intelligent agents pursuing any kind of goal. The strong form of the Orthogonality Thesis says that there's no extra difficulty or complication in the existence of an intelligent agent that pursues a goal, above and beyond the computational tractability of that goal. Suppose some strange alien came to Earth and credibly offered to pay us one million dollars' worth of new wealth every time we created a paperclip. We'd encounter no special intellectual difficulty in figuring out how to make lots of paperclips. That is, minds would readily be able to reason about: * How many paperclips would result, if I pursued a policy π0? * How can I search out a policy π that happens to have a high answer to the above question? The Orthogonality Thesis asserts that since these questions are not computationally intractable, it's possible to have an agent that tries to make paperclips without being paid, because paperclips are what it wants. The strong form of the Orthogonality Thesis says that there need be nothing especially complicated or twisted about such an agent. The Orthogonality Thesis is a statement about computer science, an assertion about the logical design space of possible cognitive agents. Orthogonality says nothing about whether a human AI researcher on Earth would want to build an AI that made paperclips, or conversely, want to make a nice AI. The Orthogonality Thesis just asserts that the space of possible designs contains AIs that make paperclips. And also AIs that are nice, to the extent there's a sense of "nice" where you could say how to be nice to someone if you were paid a billion dollars to do that, and to the extent you could name something physically achievable to do. This contrasts to inevitablist theses which might assert, for example: * "It doesn't matter what kind of AI you build, it will turn out to only pursue its own survival as a final end." * "Even if you tr

x Orthogonality Thesis — LessWrong Orthogonality Thesis Edited by Eliezer Yudkowsky , et al. last updated 20th Feb 2025 Requires: Paperclip maximizer Introduction The Orthogonality Thesis asserts that there can exist arbitrarily intelligent agents pursuing any kind of goal. The strong form of the Orthogonality Thesis says that there's no extra difficulty or complication in the existence of an intelligent agent that pursues a goal, above and beyond the computational tractability of that goal. Suppose some strange alien came to Earth and credibly offered to pay us one million dollars' worth of n

Explore this link on the map →

related reading